NFL RUSH
Vote: Peyton Manning or Andrew Luck?

When Andrew Luck came in to be the Colts QB, everyone couldn't help but compare him to Peyton Manning.  Peyton had so much success in Indianapolis and now the team was letting him go to the Broncos and getting a new passer to run the show.  

 

So how has it gone so far?  Peyton has passed for 2,404 yards and led his team to a 5-3 record.  Luck has passed for 2,404 yards and led his team to a 5-3 record.  That's not a mistake, they are tied for passing yards and their teams are basically in the same spot.  So, how do you think the Colts did with their decision to run with Luck?  

 

Which QB would you want to have on your team right now?

Be the first to like this post!

  • Post a Comment!

    * All comments are subject to review.

  • Denver Broncos

    May 7, 2013

    rip69 · draftee

    hhh

  • Denver Broncos

    May 7, 2013

    rip69 · draftee

    l

  • Denver Broncos

    May 7, 2013

    rip69 · draftee

    peyton manning is the best

  • Denver Broncos

    May 7, 2013

    rip69 · draftee

    luck is better sikeeeee ha dont even come close to peyton manning

  • Denver Broncos

    April 20, 2013

    gaguilar · draftee

    manning

  • Chicago Bears

    December 22, 2012

    timothy622 · draftee

    Peyton Manning is defintley better than Andrew Luck!!!!!!!

  • Chicago Bears

    December 22, 2012

    timothy622 · draftee

    so So SO peyton manning since he is a MVP!

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    December 1, 2012

    phi4life123 · draftee

    peyton

  • Houston Texans

    December 1, 2012

    fox900 · draftee

    go peyton

  • New England Patriots

    November 30, 2012

    pats39878312 · draftee

    LUCK IS LUCKY

  • New England Patriots

    November 30, 2012

    pats39878312 · draftee

    PEYTON MANNING THROWS PICKS EVERY GAME.

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 29, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    llllllluuuuuuuccccccckkkkkkk

  • Carolina Panthers

    November 26, 2012

    quintonsfootball · draftee

    Peyton many is way better and also has a hall of fame family

  • Denver Broncos

    November 22, 2012

    sykesdog · draftee

    i think peyton is better and evan

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 21, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    i know richie better than this really i do know him

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 20, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    andrews way freking better

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 20, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    no way richieo8

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 19, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    no way richie08

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 17, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    luck ruls

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 16, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    andrew luck gives peyton manning bad luck

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 16, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    luck by a million

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 16, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    andrew luck is way better then peyton manning becaus peyton had the worst start when he was a rooki and andrew had one of the best starts in nfl history and that is why andrew luck is clearly better

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    November 16, 2012

    BROSKI1234567 · draftee

    peyton duh luck bad

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 16, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    common andrew you can do it

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 16, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    luck makes milions of dallas $$$$$$$

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    lucks going to the superbowl

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    forget peyton manning lets go luck

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    lets go luck

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    lucks a beast

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    how in this world is better then andrew luck

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 15, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    common people we want andrew luck every body knows andrew lucks clearly better

  • Denver Broncos

    November 15, 2012

    nkfylle · 2nd string

    Andrew luck is good but i like peyton manning more.

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 15, 2012

    kewldude2 · draftee

    I don't know why Peyton Manning has more votes the Colts are 6-3 with Andrew Luck. When Peyton Manning was a rookie we went 3-13

  • Denver Broncos

    November 14, 2012

    ljtw10 · draftee

    Peyton Manning ALL DAY BOY!

  • New York Giants

    November 14, 2012

    avishockfan · draftee

    peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    November 13, 2012

    broncoscrazyfan · rookie

    Peyton's way better

  • Dallas Cowboys

    November 13, 2012

    ROWDY3114 · draftee

    Peyton Manning

  • Washington Redskins

    November 13, 2012

    austin883 · draftee

    luck

  • Green Bay Packers

    November 13, 2012

    hotstuff67 · draftee

    there both really good at QB

  • New England Patriots

    November 12, 2012

    patriots34676 · draftee

    Peyton manning

  • Denver Broncos

    November 12, 2012

    thad · draftee

    PEYTON MANNING

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 12, 2012

    evano60 · draftee

    lucks the man

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 12, 2012

    richie08 · draftee

    peyton by a lot

  • San Francisco 49ers

    November 11, 2012

    randymoss8483 · draftee

    Manning if anything

  • Baltimore Ravens

    November 11, 2012

    evano44 · draftee

    andrew luck baby

  • Denver Broncos

    November 11, 2012

    tannergobroncos · draftee

    peyton manning tho

  • Denver Broncos

    November 11, 2012

    tannergobroncos · draftee

    luck gets lucky

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 11, 2012

    indyjonwd44 · draftee

    Luck

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 11, 2012

    indyjonwd44 · draftee

    Luck

  • Denver Broncos

    November 10, 2012

    manningstyle · draftee

    Peyton is way better than luck

  • Buffalo Bills

    November 10, 2012

    kidpicks05 · starter

    Peyton

  • New York Giants

    November 10, 2012

    maulerepstein · draftee

    LOL SO PEYTON MANNING

  • Denver Broncos

    November 10, 2012

    hitmanammar · draftee

    Peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    November 10, 2012

    hitmanammar · draftee

    Peyton!!!

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    November 10, 2012

    999jlt · rookie

    Peyton

  • New England Patriots

    November 9, 2012

    lbowma01 · draftee

    Peyton

  • New England Patriots

    November 9, 2012

    lbowma01 · draftee

    Peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    November 9, 2012

    janke81 · draftee

    manning

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 9, 2012

    1coltsfan14 · draftee

    Hey, can you stop commenting suli502?

  • Green Bay Packers

    November 9, 2012

    awesomenubnub · 2nd string

    peyton is beter 1 because he just is and 2 he is a seasoned veteran who has alot of experiance in the nfl

  • Atlanta Falcons

    November 9, 2012

    suli502 · draftee

    Peyton Manning stinks.

  • Atlanta Falcons

    November 9, 2012

    suli502 · draftee

    Andrew Luck is better.

  • San Diego Chargers

    November 8, 2012

    80jman · draftee

    andrew luck is my guy

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    peytonmanning87 · draftee

    i'm going with the pro nfl player

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    abraham101 · draftee

    peyton manning

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    cjaguar · draftee

    peytin

  • Houston Texans

    November 8, 2012

    jay2380 · draftee

    luck is a rookie and peyton is a veteran and they have the same stats so i think luck is better

  • Green Bay Packers

    November 8, 2012

    packman0212 · draftee

    Peyton Manning because he has had more experience

  • Seattle Seahawks

    November 8, 2012

    novadog1 · starter

    peyton manning has wa more expereens

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    November 8, 2012

    thekidd123 · draftee

    manning

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    November 8, 2012

    chancec67 · practice squad

    Andrew Luck is a beast than Peyton Manning

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    bcdefghijklmn · draftee

    dude r ukidding me?!?!?!?!? peyton is old and overrated

  • Atlanta Falcons

    November 8, 2012

    falcons1010 · draftee

    lucky andrew

  • San Francisco 49ers

    November 8, 2012

    dominictime · draftee

    MANNING

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    patriots1051 · draftee

    peyton manning

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    November 8, 2012

    ChefBengal2 · 2nd string

    Definetily Peyton Manning.

  • San Francisco 49ers

    November 8, 2012

    49erpat4163 · draftee

    I like Luck 'cause he went to Stanford, but I think Manning is better

  • Green Bay Packers

    November 8, 2012

    rainbowman28 · draftee

    I rock

  • Jacksonville Jaguars

    November 8, 2012

    mattjags32 · draftee

    Peyton no doubt

  • Carolina Panthers

    November 8, 2012

    lrsioux · draftee

    peyton is way better

  • New York Giants

    November 8, 2012

    pananicolas23 · draftee

    Manning

  • Dallas Cowboys

    November 8, 2012

    laxgoblin · draftee

    luck

  • Minnesota Vikings

    November 8, 2012

    zachshelby · draftee

    how do they get the same!Wow!!

  • Detroit Lions

    November 8, 2012

    khabir123 · draftee

    peyton manning

  • Baltimore Ravens

    November 8, 2012

    boltimore5227 · draftee

    luck

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 8, 2012

    ojo · draftee

    i think manning

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    November 8, 2012

    aj742870 · draftee

    peyton

  • Dallas Cowboys

    November 8, 2012

    hahaha21 · draftee

    yeah thats old rookie stuff

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    bradson99 · draftee

    mannings old so I went with andrew

  • New York Giants

    November 8, 2012

    newyorkgiants101 · rookie

    Manning

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    zameer123 · draftee

    Manning has played football since like 2002 and Luck is tied witth Peyton+he is a Rookie

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    caleb915 · rookie

    manning

  • Chicago Bears

    November 8, 2012

    tyler1479 · draftee

    i am going to go with andrew luck because hes just as good as peyton and he is a rookie

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 8, 2012

    Aaronjames18 · draftee

    I think luck he has same records but he's young Peyton's 31

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    lpcowboys · draftee

    andrew is good

  • San Francisco 49ers

    November 8, 2012

    drose153 · draftee

    Anrew Luck is doing good for a rookie

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    November 8, 2012

    bengalsepic44 · 2nd string

    andrew luck

  • Miami Dolphins

    November 8, 2012

    abrohammer1 · 2nd string

    Andrew Luck

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    mattyg65 · draftee

    I'm gonna go with Payton Manning sorry colts

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 8, 2012

    jakecoltsman · rookie

    Andrew Luck is better then Pey Man in his rookie season, but right now, I would pick Pey Man.

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 8, 2012

    jakecoltsman · rookie

    I think the Colts should've kept Pey Man for 3 more years and let Luck learn from him.

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    November 8, 2012

    ziggyrb · draftee

    peyton maning no doubt

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    godblessfootball · draftee

    broncos should have kept tebow

  • Washington Redskins

    November 8, 2012

    austin883 · draftee

    andrew luck

  • Washington Redskins

    November 8, 2012

    austin883 · draftee

    luck

  • Oakland Raiders

    November 8, 2012

    diggyspider1 · draftee

    got to go with rookie

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    rypat · draftee

    LUCK

  • Baltimore Ravens

    November 8, 2012

    burner1234576 · draftee

    Peyton Manning > Andrew Luck

  • Detroit Lions

    November 8, 2012

    cpt2awzm3 · draftee

    peyton

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 8, 2012

    reggie52901 · draftee

    peyton

  • Baltimore Ravens

    November 8, 2012

    Ravensflow · practice squad

    Luck

  • New York Giants

    November 8, 2012

    gmemfan10 · draftee

    peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    November 8, 2012

    bubdog1 · draftee

    Peyton Manning

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    pats2003ty · draftee

    peyton all day

  • Atlanta Falcons

    November 8, 2012

    joshhannah24 · draftee

    Peyton by far!!!

  • New England Patriots

    November 8, 2012

    mbrady12 · draftee

    luck better

  • Tennessee Titans

    November 8, 2012

    buffulo1234 · draftee

    i already have manning on my team

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 8, 2012

    lordvoldemort01 · draftee

    Actulay Luck Cause hes younger

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 8, 2012

    lordvoldemort01 · draftee

    Peyton Manning all day!!!!!!!

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 7, 2012

    reggiewaynetd · draftee

    ANDREW LUCK!!!!!!

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    November 7, 2012

    steelersteely · draftee

    denvers peyton

  • Baltimore Ravens

    November 7, 2012

    RavensFan808 · draftee

    of course peyton manning

  • Denver Broncos

    November 7, 2012

    Herna540 · draftee

    peyton

  • Chicago Bears

    November 7, 2012

    o23f · rookie

    peyton is better then andrew luck right now but andrew luck is destined to be better

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 7, 2012

    vvhawk9 · draftee

    luk luck luck luck luck luck is B E A S T ! ! ! !

  • Denver Broncos

    November 7, 2012

    champbaily88 · draftee

    peyton maning no dout about

  • Seattle Seahawks

    November 7, 2012

    Rex22222 · draftee

    peyton is better but their matchup now is hard so luck. i have luck as wc

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    sacredheart1 · draftee

    luck is just coming along..... peyton has experience

  • New England Patriots

    November 7, 2012

    patriotsaints · 2nd string

    peyton

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    November 7, 2012

    incrediblemrjd · 2nd string

    Peyton. He leads the league in QBR, and the last four years, the QB who leads the lead in QBR has won MVP.

  • Atlanta Falcons

    November 7, 2012

    besserfalcon · draftee

    Andrew Luck! Why because he has made more pass yards and running yards than peytonmanning

  • Washington Redskins

    November 7, 2012

    leee · draftee

    peyton

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 7, 2012

    jkorz34 · draftee

    go mr lucky=andrew luck

  • Seattle Seahawks

    November 7, 2012

    Caidan18 · draftee

    Peyton manning

  • Seattle Seahawks

    November 7, 2012

    hunterzeus · draftee

    peyton manning is sooooooo good

  • Denver Broncos

    November 7, 2012

    49fan2003 · draftee

    peyton

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    soccerdud655 · draftee

    luck is a rookie and has years to go and manning is getting old so i bet at least 2- 5 more years for him

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    nicks888 · draftee

    Peyton Manning, no dought about it. Lucks a rookie, Mannings a Pro.

  • Arizona Cardinals

    November 7, 2012

    trentswim · draftee

    Peyton time in Tennessee

  • Tennessee Titans

    November 7, 2012

    neylandvols · draftee

    peyton is way better

  • New York Jets

    November 7, 2012

    sfromowitz · draftee

    peyton manning

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 7, 2012

    theaxe41 · draftee

    manning is little old

  • Chicago Bears

    November 7, 2012

    JayCutlerTD · practice squad

    At this rate Luck will be the next Joe Montana. He already set a rookie record!

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 7, 2012

    theaxe41 · draftee

    Luck gets a better year, so luck

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 7, 2012

    psn · draftee

    Go Peyton Mannig!!!!!!!

  • Carolina Panthers

    November 7, 2012

    cagermatt · draftee

    peyton manning's a future hall of famer. you can't top that

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 7, 2012

    matt10802 · draftee

    peyton manning is beast!!!!!!!

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 7, 2012

    matt10802 · draftee

    manning

  • New Orleans Saints

    November 7, 2012

    matt10802 · draftee

    peyton is a pro bowl winner and super bowl + mvp

  • Green Bay Packers

    November 7, 2012

    Pack515 · 2nd string

    Peyton Manning is AWESOME!!!!!

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    giantssuperfan48 · draftee

    peyton is way better

  • San Diego Chargers

    November 7, 2012

    dst11 · draftee

    go manning

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    maulerepstein · draftee

    manning to good love the guy

  • Denver Broncos

    November 7, 2012

    iamfluffy · draftee

    peyton is more better

  • New York Jets

    November 7, 2012

    ryanlion99 · draftee

    andrew luck because he can throw and run

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 7, 2012

    gopman · draftee

    i like andrew but you have to respt peyton

  • Indianapolis Colts

    November 7, 2012

    eancool · draftee

    go luck

  • Dallas Cowboys

    November 7, 2012

    cowboy8919 · draftee

    manning

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    November 7, 2012

    gokarts123 · rookie

    peyton whoa dude this guy is so whaly

  • Buffalo Bills

    November 7, 2012

    beasy7 · draftee

    Go Luck

  • Buffalo Bills

    November 7, 2012

    beasy7 · draftee

    Go Peyton!

  • Cleveland Browns

    November 7, 2012

    kdog335 · draftee

    luck

  • New York Giants

    November 7, 2012

    ethanrobert4000 · draftee

    Luck because he will get better over time and peyton is starting to get rusty

  • Dallas Cowboys

    November 7, 2012

    bradshawsp · draftee

    peyton and luck are awesome