NFL RUSH
NFL Top 100 Players: Manning vs Manning

The NFL Top 100 Players of 2012 placed Peyton Manning at number 50 on the list and that means that his brother, Eli, will likely place ahead of him.  Who is really the better Manning?  We brought together two NFLRushers to argue the point.

 

Why ELI is ahead of PEYTON in the Top 100

By:  DPSRULES

 

Are you kidding me?  Are we even having this conversation!?!  It's ELI all the way.   Let's look at some facts.  He's the 2012 Super Bowl Champion and the 2012 Super Bowl MVP.  He orchestrated an astonishing string of clutch victories down the stretch that would make brother Peyton drool!   Peyton didn't take a snap in 2011, meanwhile 2011 was pretty good for his little bro.  Eli passed Peyton in the Super Bowl ring and Super Bowl MVP count.  Not a bad year since ELI wasn't even in Top 100 for 2011.  Some list!   By the way, Peyton was number 2 on that list. Who was number one?  Tom Brady!   That's funny, because in each head-to-head Super Bowl appearance Eli  had against Brady - you guess it!   

 

Boom! Game over.  Don't ever read the Peyton article!

 

Peyton Manning Still the Best

By: PickSix

 

It always has been this way and always will be this way.  Peyton Manning is not only the best Manning to play QB, he is the best player in NFL history to play QB.  All you have to do is look at the facts.  Peyton is the only four-time MVP in NFL history. He is ranked third all-time in each category of TD passes (399), passes completed (4,682), and passing yards (54,828). He has led the Colts to nine straight 10-win seasons.  The same Colts who suddenly went from perennial Super Bowl favorites to the WORST team in the NFL without Peyton Manning.  That should show everyone how little help Peyton has received.  

 

What's Eli doing over in New York? Playing with one of the top defenses the NFL has ever seen and relying on miracle catches from elite receivers to win games.  Eli threw for over 4,000 yards his last three seasons, you say? Peyton has done that 11 times in his 13 years playing.  Peyton's career completion percentage in 64.9% (which ranks fourth all-time).  You know when the last time Eli was that accurate through an NFL season? Never.  Eli has never been better by the numbers than his big brother, Peyton, and that won't change in 2012.

 

Check out Peyton Manning, #50 on the NFL Top 100 Players.

 

Who should be higher on the NFL Top 100 Players list?

Be the first to like this post!

  • Post a Comment!

    * All comments are subject to review.

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    December 28, 2012

    josebroncos84 · draftee

    PEYTON MANNING

  • Green Bay Packers

    August 26, 2012

    jerell90 · draftee

    Eli Manning

  • Denver Broncos

    August 23, 2012

    skateboard20 · draftee

    tie

  • Miami Dolphins

    August 8, 2012

    crazycooper · draftee

    i say Eli

  • Green Bay Packers

    August 8, 2012

    elimanningnyqb3 · draftee

    GIANTS CAN BEAT DA BRONCOS

  • Denver Broncos

    August 7, 2012

    gabrieljurado814 · draftee

    BRONCOS CAN BEAT DA GIANTS

  • New England Patriots

    July 30, 2012

    durantheman · draftee

    giants vs broncos

  • New York Giants

    July 25, 2012

    PeyliManning28 · draftee

    My name comes from Pey in Peyton and Li in Eli. Also 10 plus 18 is 28

  • Seattle Seahawks

    July 24, 2012

    ttp123 · draftee

    payton didnt play eli did

  • New York Jets

    July 15, 2012

    jetsrock68 · draftee

    they have lead two great teams

  • New York Jets

    July 15, 2012

    jetsrock68 · draftee

    they are equaly great but i would say Peyton

  • New England Patriots

    July 13, 2012

    barrel123 · draftee

    Before it has a Revalaty. The Giants and the Colts. Now we Have Peyton with the Broncos so they have a new Rivalety

  • Carolina Panthers

    July 13, 2012

    newton99 · rookie

    peyton for alltime

  • Carolina Panthers

    July 13, 2012

    newton99 · rookie

    eli for 2012

  • New York Giants

    July 11, 2012

    Stormcrushers · draftee

    Eli Wooo Hooo

  • New York Giants

    July 6, 2012

    Broadwayjoe614 · draftee

    Better be Eli !!!!!!!

  • New York Giants

    July 6, 2012

    Broadwayjoe614 · draftee

    Definitely Eli manning

  • New York Giants

    July 5, 2012

    giant12351 · draftee

    don't know they are both extremely talented

  • Green Bay Packers

    July 5, 2012

    12arod · draftee

    Eli Because Payton is bad Joke

  • Tampa Bay Buccaneers

    June 26, 2012

    FootballForU · draftee

    actually i like manning

  • Tampa Bay Buccaneers

    June 26, 2012

    FootballForU · draftee

    eli

  • Denver Broncos

    June 26, 2012

    joel19 · draftee

    peyton is way better

  • New York Giants

    June 23, 2012

    kevin3372 · draftee

    you what

  • Seattle Seahawks

    June 21, 2012

    Seahawksbli · draftee

    Peyton

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    June 16, 2012

    dejax1234 · draftee

    PEYTON!!!!!!!

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    June 16, 2012

    dejax1234 · draftee

    THE CLASH OF THE BROTHERS

  • Denver Broncos

    June 16, 2012

    Boo925 · 2nd string

    Bros!

  • Baltimore Ravens

    June 15, 2012

    ravenfoot · draftee

    the football brothers

  • Denver Broncos

    June 12, 2012

    PKRickey24 · draftee

    what you talkin' bout cards7410 peyton is so better

  • Arizona Cardinals

    June 12, 2012

    cards7410 · draftee

    Eli Manning is way better.

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    June 12, 2012

    Steelersk · draftee

    i belive in Eli

  • Denver Broncos

    June 11, 2012

    taconachos · draftee

    go peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    June 11, 2012

    taconachos · draftee

    I disagree , peyton is taking us to the super bowl , but I still want Tebow

  • Kansas City Chiefs

    June 9, 2012

    cheifs2001 · draftee

    peyton manning better becuase he got 4 nfl mvp awards

  • San Francisco 49ers

    June 9, 2012

    hershey6231 · draftee

    peyton is great and all but im not sure if he could bring the broncos to the super bowl

  • New York Giants

    June 8, 2012

    fireman325 · draftee

    eli's better because he'swon two superbowls peytons only won one

  • Atlanta Falcons

    June 7, 2012

    RYAN564321 · draftee

    MANNING IS GOING TO WIN

  • Denver Broncos

    June 6, 2012

    qcribb · draftee

    go peyton

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    June 5, 2012

    ChefBengal2 · 2nd string

    Go Peyton

  • Denver Broncos

    June 5, 2012

    Broncosfan02 · draftee

    peyton is better

  • Minnesota Vikings

    June 5, 2012

    johnathan125 · draftee

    eli manning

  • Cleveland Browns

    June 4, 2012

    BERNIEBERNIE · draftee

    Peyton Manning is WAY better!!!!!!

  • Denver Broncos

    June 4, 2012

    Crush23 · draftee

    i think peyton is better. im not sayin that just cuz i like the broncos. peyton may have sat out last season but he is still better than eli

  • Dallas Cowboys

    June 4, 2012

    racicot18 · draftee

    peyton deserves more credit because the team around him is not that good

  • Denver Broncos

    June 4, 2012

    kozicke18 · draftee

    Peyton is better, eli won the super bowl cause Peyton never played a game in the season

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    June 4, 2012

    sward0 · draftee

    peytons way better

  • San Diego Chargers

    June 4, 2012

    jayman323 · draftee

    eli is better than peyton

  • Detroit Lions

    June 3, 2012

    husseinlakha · draftee

    eeyashu shalishma

  • Dallas Cowboys

    June 3, 2012

    joeboys · draftee

    eli won super bowls.peyton lost superbowls

  • Indianapolis Colts

    June 3, 2012

    alUCKind · draftee

    DON'T BE PRISONERS OF THE MOMENT. Peyton is the supeirior brother

  • Pittsburgh Steelers

    June 3, 2012

    Steelersk · draftee

    peytons old eli better

  • Green Bay Packers

    June 2, 2012

    isaiaha · draftee

    peyton is goin to be better than eli

  • Detroit Lions

    June 2, 2012

    sowm123 · draftee

    :(

  • New York Giants

    June 2, 2012

    Tmagic · draftee

    Eli is way way way better

  • Cleveland Browns

    June 2, 2012

    connecter45 · draftee

    Peyton Manning is better

  • New York Giants

    June 2, 2012

    gfi6454k · draftee

    eli

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 2, 2012

    saintsfan015 · draftee

    eli

  • Cincinnati Bengals

    June 2, 2012

    blitz215 · draftee

    eli

  • Denver Broncos

    June 2, 2012

    tebowrocks87 · draftee

    go peyton he rocks

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    June 2, 2012

    TSAYRE · draftee

    eli

  • Philadelphia Eagles

    June 2, 2012

    TSAYRE · draftee

    eli but patton is better

  • New York Giants

    June 2, 2012

    broncoboy45 · draftee

    E L I

  • Atlanta Falcons

    June 2, 2012

    TonyTE88 · draftee

    both gone to superbowl

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 2, 2012

    footballnat · draftee

    hi u guys

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 2, 2012

    footballnat · draftee

    eli is best

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 2, 2012

    footballnat · draftee

    eli it is

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 2, 2012

    footballnat · draftee

    eli mannin is way better

  • Detroit Lions

    June 1, 2012

    zrockflip · draftee

    I think Manning is better :D

  • Baltimore Ravens

    June 1, 2012

    Ravensflow · draftee

    Eli

  • Green Bay Packers

    June 1, 2012

    TheMan13421 · draftee

    Not only is peyton aging, but eli has better people around him. Peyton's better.

  • New York Jets

    June 1, 2012

    PaulyD03 · draftee

    gotta go with Eli

  • Atlanta Falcons

    June 1, 2012

    wolfbite · draftee

    of course a BRONCO fan would deffend peyton!!

  • Atlanta Falcons

    June 1, 2012

    wolfbite · draftee

    of course a BRONCO

  • Houston Texans

    June 1, 2012

    XRowdyX · draftee

    Eli Manning all the way!

  • Denver Broncos

    June 1, 2012

    walkerbronco · draftee

    peyton is better

  • San Francisco 49ers

    June 1, 2012

    antonjamero2 · draftee

    eli manning is better

  • San Francisco 49ers

    June 1, 2012

    checkers23 · draftee

    Eli Maning is better because he won more Superbowls

  • Carolina Panthers

    June 1, 2012

    PranavRama1 · draftee

    I think Peyton is better

  • Denver Broncos

    June 1, 2012

    gfgolfer · draftee

    peyton is better

  • Atlanta Falcons

    June 1, 2012

    wolfbite · draftee

    eli all the way!!hes got 2 rings and peytons neck didnt work last year

  • Green Bay Packers

    June 1, 2012

    ejam1601 · draftee

    Peyton rules !!!!!!!

  • New Orleans Saints

    June 1, 2012

    bensfootball · draftee

    eli!!!!!!!

  • Seattle Seahawks

    June 1, 2012

    Rex22222 · draftee

    Eli Manning, But Peyton is a close second

  • Atlanta Falcons

    May 31, 2012

    frohawk12 · draftee

    two words two rings eli all the way

  • New York Jets

    May 31, 2012

    en6501 · draftee

    hey pick six, what about brady, or montana, or terry bradshaw

  • New York Jets

    May 31, 2012

    en6501 · draftee

    no offense to giants fans

  • New York Jets

    May 31, 2012

    en6501 · draftee

    peyton shoud be hogher than eli

  • Indianapolis Colts

    May 31, 2012

    jakecoltsman · draftee

    I had Pey Man the best Manning since his rookie season. But since he didn't even took a snap last year, I would now say E-Man is better then Pey Man.

  • Baltimore Ravens

    May 31, 2012

    RavensFan808 · draftee

    wonder why peyton is even in the 50's place when he didnt play should be #100 place

  • New York Giants

    May 31, 2012

    Anish82003 · draftee

    my gosh eli is bosssss!his 63 yard pass to manningham was awesome

  • New England Patriots

    May 31, 2012

    ileyba1 · draftee

    it is even

  • Detroit Lions

    May 31, 2012

    BoyScout99 · draftee

    Just to let everybody know, I did say that Eli should be higher on the NFL Top 100 list because I don't think Peyton should be on it at all because he didn't play. But I still think Peyton is better.

  • Detroit Lions

    May 31, 2012

    BoyScout99 · draftee

    Peyton by far. Of course, Eli does have more Superbowl rings, but that's only because I believe he got lucky. In the regular season this year, Eli was an okay quarterback. But two years ago, the Colts almost won the Superbowl. This year, without Peyton, they almost went 0-16.